A 10-member delegation met poll officials in Delhi, which assured a decision within two hours. In Bhopal, Congress workers hung an RSS uniform at the CEO office gate.

The Congress party on Wednesday knocked on the doors of the Election Commission of India (ECI), challenging the rejection of its Rajya Sabha candidate Meenakshi Natarajan’s nomination papers in Madhya Pradesh. The move came less than 24 hours after Returning Officer (RO) Arpit Sharma invalidated her candidature, triggering sharp political reactions and street protests across the state.

Delhi Meeting, EC Assurance

A Congress delegation, including senior leaders K.C. Venugopal, Jairam Ramesh, Bhupesh Baghel, and Sachin Pilot, met with poll officials in the capital. Party MP Abhishek Manu Singhvi, a senior advocate, argued that the RO’s decision had no legal basis.

“The grounds on which the nomination was rejected do not exist in the law. There was no criminal case that required disclosure,” Singhvi told reporters after the meeting. He clarified that Natarajan had only received a court notice, not a formal charge. “A notice asking if proceedings should begin is not a pending criminal case.”

According to Leader of Opposition in the MP Assembly Umang Singhar, the Commission assured the delegation of a decision within two hours.

Bhopal Protest Turns Symbolic

In the state capital, the protest took an unusual turn. Congress workers gathered outside the office of the Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) but found the gates shut. In response, they hung a uniform of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) on the main gate before leaving the spot.

The action was a direct rejoinder to the BJP’s repeated claims linking Congress to a specific ideological posture. Meanwhile, a separate collective fast was underway at Roshanpura Square in Bhopal, where former Chief Minister Digvijaya Singh and several other leaders sat on a day-long hunger strike.

The Legal Dispute

The controversy revolves around a private complaint filed against Natarajan in a Hyderabad court. The RO had cited the non-disclosure of this case, arguing that a summons issued on September 17, 2025, made it a “pending” matter.

Singhvi, however, rejected this interpretation. “Under election law, a candidate only needs to disclose cases where the court has taken cognizance and framed charges for an offence carrying two years or more in jail. Here, the magistrate hasn’t even taken cognizance yet,” he explained. He termed the RO’s decision “legally malicious.”

A Contrast in Jharkhand

Adding to Congress’s argument of a double standard, party workers pointed to a simultaneous election process in Jharkhand. There, the RO has declared the nomination of NDA-backed independent candidate Parimal Nathwani as valid, despite objections from Congress over discrepancies in his name on affidavits.

A Congress functionary noted that while the Jharkhand RO gave time until the next day to respond to objections, the MP RO rejected Natarajan’s form within hours of raising a query. “Two states, two rules in one election,” said state women’s Congress chief Reena Borasi.

Political Fallout

The ruling BJP dismissed the protests as a face-saving tactic. State minister Vishwas Sarang alleged the Congress deliberately filed a defective nomination, fearing cross-voting by its own MLAs. “They knew at least 25 of their legislators would vote for our candidate. To save their own shame, they got the form cancelled,” Sarang claimed.

Congress legislators, however, remained defiant. Some lawmakers in Bhopal raised the pitch, with MLA Dinesh Gurjar making sharp remarks about being the “first to throw a stone” at the chief minister’s residence if a protest was called. Other leaders, like Vikrant Bhuria, labelled the poll panel a "commission of brokers."

With the last date for withdrawal of nominations still open, the Congress has indicated it may approach the Supreme Court if the EC does not rule in its favour.